TL;DR: Police say the murder and potentially months-long torture of a trans man in New York is not a hate crime, explaining that some of those charged for the crime are also LGBTQIA+. They've called on communities to avoid speculation in the search for justice for Sam Nordquist.
Five people in New York have been charged with murdering a transgender man, after subjecting him to “repeated acts of violence and torture” over a number of months.
Police identified Precious Arzuaga, 38; Jennifer Quijano, 30; Kyle Sage, 33; Patrick Goodwin, 30; and Emily Motyka, 19, as suspects in Nordquist’s death. They face charges of second-degree murder with depraved indifference - The Guardian
Because of the current anti-trans legislative agenda in the US, and a long-term rise in violence towards transgender people, the case has caused a great deal of alarm and upset within the LGBTQIA+ community.
However, the police have now said there is "no evidence" the case is a hate crime. That's because it's understood those charged with the murder are also members of the community.
In a joint statement, the state police and District Attorney James Ritts said, "To help alleviate the understandable concern his murder could be a hate crime, we are disclosing that Sam and his assailants were known to each other, identified as LGBTQ+, and at least one of the defendants lived with Sam in the time period leading up to the instant offence."
Who was Sam Nordquist?
Sam Nordquist was a 24-year-old Black trans man who lived in Oakdale, Minnesota with his mother, Linda Nordquist.
He left home in September to "meet an online girlfriend" and was due to return two weeks later, but did not. His sister later said that the trip was also to meet Precious Arzuaga, one of those charged with his murder.
His mother said the last thing Sam said is, "I love you and I’ll call you tomorrow." Speaking to local news Kare 11 she said: "Tomorrow came and I never heard a word. He sounded so sad, really sad. And Sam is an outgoing person.”- them
What do we know about the case? CW: Upsetting details, murder, torture
Police said the case is "one of the most horrific crimes" they had ever seen and that Nordquist was subjected to "deeply disturbing" abuse for several months, starting in December.
Evidence suggests that Nordquist was subjected to months-long physical abuse before his death, with Ontario County District Attorney James Ritts calling the case “by far the worst homicide investigation that our office has ever been part of” - BBC
It's understood the abuse took place at a number of locations, including roadside motel Patty’s Lodge in Hopewell, New York. Authorities began searching for Nordquist after he was reported missing Feb. 9. They found his body in a field in a different county.
Analysis: RIP Sam Nordquist
100 people gathered in below-zero temperatures this week on the steps of the state Capitol of Minnesota, St. Paul, to hold vigil for Nordquist - MPR
Police have called on community members to avoid speculating about Nordquist's death; we should honour this and be driven by the facts we have when discussing what looks like a horrific injustice done to a trans man described by his family as having "a heart of gold".
Help us deliver quality queer journalism, created by marginalised queer creatives
February 2025 marks our third birthday - and whether you're new, or a long time supporter I need you to know we're at a critical juncture.
QueerAF, the UK’s beloved and biggest queer newsletter and largest advocate of queer creatives, needs your help to stay strong, thriving and fighting for you.
This weekend, we're launching our annual LGBT+ History Month crowdfunder. This year's appeal is integral to our future.
In an age of Trump and Musk trying to take away our liberties and filter our content, we need your help to cut through the noise.
We’ve also been hit by business tax rises, inflation and increasing costs. Your support will help us continue providing a vital service for the LGBTQIA+ community.
Information is a tool for liberation, and it shouldn’t be a luxury, so this crowdfunder will keep QueerAF’s newsletter free for everyone as well as allowing us to invest in marginalised creatives and critical investigative journalism.
